Small Biopsy Specimens Reliably Indicate p16 Expression Status of Oropharyngeal Squamous Cell Carcinoma

Human papillomavirus (HPV)-related oropharyngeal squamous cell carcinoma (SCC) is associated with favorable patient survival. Tumor HPV status at primary diagnosis is critical for proper management, and p16 immunohistochemistry (IHC) has emerged as a reliable, single, surrogate marker. It is not known, however, if small biopsy specimens are completely adequate for p16 evaluation. From a database of oropharyngeal SCC for which p16 IHC and histologic typing were already performed, all patients (32) who had available in-house primary tumor biopsy specimens and also subsequent surgical resections were analyzed. p16 IHC was performed along with histologic typing into: Type 1 keratinizing SCC, Type 2 nonkeratinizing SCC with maturation, and Type 3 nonkeratinizing SCC. Staining was graded on both biopsies and resections as follows: 0 = negative; 1+ = 1-25% of tumor cells positive; 2+ = 26-50%; 3+ = 51-75%; 4+ = 76-100%. Strictly considering p16 score, perfect biopsy-resection correlation was present in 28 of 32 cases (85%), including 6/9 (67%) Type 1, 6/7 (86%) Type 2, and 16/16 (100%) Type 3 cases. Considering p16 expression binarily as 51% tumor cell staining or more (3+ or 4+) being positive and lesser amounts (0, 1+, or 2+) as being negative, there was perfect biopsy-resection correlation for all 32 cases. With p16 expression in resection specimens considered the gold standard, p16 IHC in biopsies was both 100% sensitive and specific. Our results demonstrate that p16 staining in diagnostic biopsies reliably reflects whole tumor staining results, and suggest that biopsies do not suffer from false negatives or positives.