TY - JOUR
T1 - Reliability of the ROCK osteochondritis dissecans knee arthroscopy classification system - Multi-center validation study
AU - Carey, James L.
AU - Wall, Eric J.
AU - Shea, Kevin G.
AU - Grimm, Nathan L.
AU - Anderson, Allen F.
AU - Edmonds, Eric W.
AU - Chambers, Henry G.
AU - Heyworth, Benton E.
AU - Kocher, Mininder S.
AU - Lyon, Roger M.
AU - Murnaghan, Michael Lucas
AU - Nissen, Carl W.
AU - Polousky, John
AU - Weiss, Jennifer
AU - Wright, Rick W.
N1 - Publisher Copyright:
© The Author(s) 2013.
PY - 2013/9
Y1 - 2013/9
N2 - Objectives: Very few predictors of healing have been identified to help guide OCD treatment decisions for patients, families and physicians. As this condition is not common, multi-center study groups will be necessary to determine optimal diagnostic and treatment strategies. For staging systems to be useful, there must be agreement among observers of each stage, and from different centers. Although arthroscopic staging systems exist for OCD, none have been tested for intra-observer and inter-observer reliability. Using an expert consensus method, the ROCK OCD study group developed an arthroscopy classification system for OCD of the knee. The purpose of this study was to determine the reliability of an OCD classification system in a multicenter study group. Methods: We developed a classification system for arthroscopic evaluation of OCD of the knee based on the experience of a 13 centers experienced in the care of OCD. The classification system produced 6 arthroscopic categories (Cue Ball, Shadow, Wrinkle in the Rug, Locked Door, Trap Door, and Crater). A training module including arthroscopic photos, iconic sketches, and representative videos was developed to describe each stage. A total of 30 representative arthroscopic videos were viewed by 10 orthopedic surgeons who had not participated in the video case selection and preparation. After 60 days, the 30 videos were reviewed a second time in a new, randomly selected order and classified. An inter-rater reliability assessment was performed using the intra-class correlation method. Results: The intra-class correlation coefficient was 0.92, indicating a very good to excellent reliability of this classification system amongst orthopedic surgeons within the ROCK group. Conclusion: The ROCK OCD Knee arthroscopy classification system demonstrated high reliability. Relatively rare conditions will require multi-center study groups to perform high quality outcome studies. This classification system will facilitate multi-center studies for OCD.
AB - Objectives: Very few predictors of healing have been identified to help guide OCD treatment decisions for patients, families and physicians. As this condition is not common, multi-center study groups will be necessary to determine optimal diagnostic and treatment strategies. For staging systems to be useful, there must be agreement among observers of each stage, and from different centers. Although arthroscopic staging systems exist for OCD, none have been tested for intra-observer and inter-observer reliability. Using an expert consensus method, the ROCK OCD study group developed an arthroscopy classification system for OCD of the knee. The purpose of this study was to determine the reliability of an OCD classification system in a multicenter study group. Methods: We developed a classification system for arthroscopic evaluation of OCD of the knee based on the experience of a 13 centers experienced in the care of OCD. The classification system produced 6 arthroscopic categories (Cue Ball, Shadow, Wrinkle in the Rug, Locked Door, Trap Door, and Crater). A training module including arthroscopic photos, iconic sketches, and representative videos was developed to describe each stage. A total of 30 representative arthroscopic videos were viewed by 10 orthopedic surgeons who had not participated in the video case selection and preparation. After 60 days, the 30 videos were reviewed a second time in a new, randomly selected order and classified. An inter-rater reliability assessment was performed using the intra-class correlation method. Results: The intra-class correlation coefficient was 0.92, indicating a very good to excellent reliability of this classification system amongst orthopedic surgeons within the ROCK group. Conclusion: The ROCK OCD Knee arthroscopy classification system demonstrated high reliability. Relatively rare conditions will require multi-center study groups to perform high quality outcome studies. This classification system will facilitate multi-center studies for OCD.
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84969297994&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.1177/2325967113S00074
DO - 10.1177/2325967113S00074
M3 - Comment/debate
AN - SCOPUS:84969297994
SN - 2325-9671
VL - 1
JO - Orthopaedic Journal of Sports Medicine
JF - Orthopaedic Journal of Sports Medicine
IS - 4
ER -