Intermediate-term to long-term outcome of surgically and nonsurgically treated congenital, isolated radial head dislocation

Matthew J. Bengard, Ryan P. Calfee, Jennifer A. Steffen, Charles A. Goldfarb

Research output: Contribution to journalArticlepeer-review

12 Scopus citations

Abstract

Purpose: Adolescent patients with congenital radial head dislocation presenting with pain and limitation in motion might benefit from radial head excision. We report objective and patient-rated data for patients treated with radial head excision and those followed nonsurgically. We hypothesized that surgery would improve pain and motion and that outcomes and the need for additional surgery would be similar between the 2 groups. Methods: We reviewed our surgical logs and identified 16 patients (10 treated surgically and 6 treated nonsurgically) for participation. At a mean of 10 years for the surgical group and 16 years after initial office visit for the nonsurgical group, we collected patient-rated and objective data, including range of motion, strength, and pain at the wrist or elbow. Results: Eight of 16 patients had bilateral dislocations. Preoperative and postoperative elbow flexion (137° versus 135°) and extension (27° versus 23°) were unchanged in surgically treated patients. Forearm rotation was improved after surgery (100° versus 119°). Carrying angle was similar between surgical (17°) and nonsurgical (13°) elbows, but surgically treated elbows had significantly different ulnar variance at +4.9 mm compared to -0.4 mm for the nonsurgically treated patients. Surgically treated patients had significant improvement in elbow pain following radial head excision. Final Quick Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder, and Hand scores were similar between groups, although there were lower mean scores among nonsurgically treated patients. Conclusions: Radial head excision in patients with symptomatic, isolated, congenital radial head dislocations resulted in substantial pain relief and patient satisfaction but modest improvement in forearm rotation and no improvement in elbow flexion-extension. Furthermore, more than 25% of the surgically treated limbs developed wrist pain and needed additional surgery. The nonsurgical group did not lose motion, develop pain, or need surgery. This information might help make the decision whether to excise the radial head in patients with symptomatic, congenital radial head dislocation. Type of study/level of evidence: Therapeutic III.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)2495-2501
Number of pages7
JournalJournal of Hand Surgery
Volume37
Issue number12
DOIs
StatePublished - Dec 2012

Keywords

  • Congenital
  • isolated
  • nonsurgical
  • radial head dislocation
  • surgical

Fingerprint

Dive into the research topics of 'Intermediate-term to long-term outcome of surgically and nonsurgically treated congenital, isolated radial head dislocation'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this