Inactivation of specific Pseudomonas aeruginosa biofilm factors does not alter virulence in infected cholesteatomas

Hypothesis: When experimental cholesteatomas are infected with Pseudomonas aeruginosa (PA) mutants lacking factors associated with the formation of biofilms, host defenses are more effective against these strains when compared with wild-type strains (PAO1 and OPPA8) in preventing tissue destruction.

Background: Previous studies have identified biofilms within chronically infected aural cholesteatomas. These infected cholesteatomas are associated with increased tissue destruction. Because biofilms are highly resistant to host defenses leading to prolonged infection, we propose that the biofilm phenotype of P. aeruginosa may be a virulence factor leading to persistence of infection and increased tissue destruction.

Methods: Aural cholesteatomas were induced in Mongolian gerbils. At the time of induction, the ear canals were inoculated with wild-type (PAO1 and OPPA8) and biofilm-deficient (PAO1 ΔpilA, PAO1 algD::aacC1 and PAO1 galU::aacC1) strains of P. aeruginosa. After 8 weeks, the size of the cholesteatomas and levels of bone destruction and deposition were measured using microCT scanning and double fluorochrome bone labeling.

Result: Infected cholesteatomas resulted in increased growth, bone destruction, and bone deposition when compared with vehicle-only controls. We observed no differences between the wild-type (biofilm forming) and the biofilm-deficient strains of P. aeruginosa.

Conclusion: Our hypothesis that biofilm formation is a virulence factor in cholesteatomas infected with P. aeruginosa was not supported. A number of interpretations of these data are reasonable. It is possible that biofilms are not critical in infected cholesteatomas. Alternatively, the mutants that are deficient in generating biofilms in vitro may be able to form effective biofilms in vivo using alternative pathways.