TY - JOUR
T1 - Documenting the Recovery of Vascular Services in European Centres Following the Initial COVID-19 Pandemic Peak
T2 - Results from a Multicentre Collaborative Study
AU - The VERN COVER study collaborative
AU - Ruffino, Maria Antonella
AU - Chan, Sharon
AU - Coughlin, Patrick
AU - Awopetu, Ayoola
AU - Stather, Philip
AU - Lane, Tristan
AU - Theodosiou, Dimitrios
AU - Ahmed, Mohamed Abozeid
AU - Vasudevan, Thodur
AU - Ibrahim, Mohammed
AU - Al Maadany, Faraj
AU - Eljareh, Mohamed
AU - Alkhafeefi, Fatimah Saad
AU - Coscas, Raphael
AU - Ünal, Ertekin Utku
AU - Pulli, Raffaele
AU - Zacà, Sergio
AU - Angiletta, Domenico
AU - Kotsis, Thomas
AU - Moawad, Magdy
AU - Tozzi, Matteo
AU - Patelis, Nikolaos
AU - Lazaris, Andreas M.
AU - Chuen, Jason
AU - Croo, Alexander
AU - Tsolaki, Elpiniki
AU - Zenunaj, Gladiol
AU - Kamal, Dhafer
AU - Tolba, Mahmoud MH
AU - Maresch, Martin
AU - Khetarpaul, Vipul
AU - Mills, Joseph
AU - Gangwani, Gaurav
AU - Elahwal, Mohamed
AU - Khalil, Rana
AU - Azab, Mohammed A.
AU - Mahomed, Anver
AU - Whiston, Richard
AU - Contractor, Ummul
AU - Esposito, Davide
AU - Pratesi, Carlo
AU - Giacomelli, Elena
AU - Troncoso, Martín Veras
AU - Elkouri, Stephane
AU - Johansson, Flavia Gentile
AU - Dodos, Ilias
AU - Benezit, Marie
AU - Vidoedo, José
AU - Rocha-Neves, João
AU - Pereira-Neves, António Henrique
AU - Dias-Neto, Marina Felicidade
AU - Campos Jácome, Ana Filipa
AU - Loureiro, Luis
AU - Silva, Ivone
AU - Garza-Herrera, Rodrigo
AU - Canata, Victor
AU - Bezard, Charlotte
AU - Bowser, Kathryn
AU - Tobar, Jorge Felipe
AU - Vera, Carlos Gomez
AU - Parra, Carolina Salinas
AU - Lopez, Eugenia
AU - Serra, Yvis Gadelha
AU - Varela, Juan
AU - Rubio, Vanessa
AU - Victoria, Gerardo
AU - Johnson, Adam
AU - O'Banion, Leigh Ann
AU - Makar, Ragai
AU - Tantawy, Tamer Ghatwary
AU - Storck, Martin
AU - Jongkind, Vincent
AU - falah, Orwa
AU - McBride, Olivia
AU - Isik, Arda
AU - Papaioannou, Athanasios
AU - Ocke Reis, Paulo Eduardo
AU - Bracale, Umberto Marcello
AU - Atkins, Ellie
AU - Tinelli, Giovanni
AU - Scott, Emma
AU - Wales, Lucy
AU - Sivaharan, Ashwin
AU - Priona, Georgia
AU - Nesbitt, Craig
AU - Grainger, Tabitha
AU - Shelmerdine, Lauren
AU - Chong, Patrick
AU - Bajwa, Adnan
AU - Arwynck, Luke
AU - Hadjievangelou, Nancy
AU - Elbasty, Ahmed
AU - Rubio, Oscar
AU - Ricardo, Michael
AU - Ulloa, Jorge H.
AU - Tarazona, Marcos
AU - Pabon, Manuel
AU - Pitoulias, Georgios
AU - Corless, Kevin
AU - Ioannidis, Orestis
AU - Friedrich, Oliver
AU - Van Herzeele, Isabelle
AU - Vijaynagar, Badri
AU - Cohnert, Tina
AU - Bell, Rachel
AU - Moore, Hayley
AU - Saha, Prakash
AU - Gifford, Edward
AU - Laine, Matti
AU - Barkat, Adel
AU - Karkos, Christos
AU - Binti Safri, Lenny Suryani
AU - Buitron, Gabriel
AU - Del Castillo, Javier
AU - Carrera, Paul
AU - Salinas, Nilson
AU - Biagioni, Rodrigo Bruno
AU - Benites, Sergio
AU - Mafla, César Andrés
AU - Pian, Putera Mas
AU - Albino, Pereira
AU - Serrano, Ernesto
AU - Marin, Andres
AU - González, Marco
AU - Foreroga, Marsha
AU - Russo, Alejandro
AU - Reyes, Andrés
AU - Guglielmone, Daniel
AU - Grillo, Lorena
AU - Flumignan, Ronald
AU - Palones, Francisco Gomez
AU - Silveira, Pierre Galvagni
AU - Ramely, Rosnelifaizur Bin
AU - Edeiken, Sara
AU - Chetter, Ian
AU - Green, Lucy
AU - Sudarsanam, Abhilash
AU - Lyons, Oliver
AU - Lemmon, Gary
AU - Neville, Richard
AU - Castelli, Mariano
AU - Hinojosa, Carlos A.
AU - Carvajal, Rubén Rodríguez
AU - Rivera, Aksim
AU - Wong, Peng
AU - Drudi, Laura
AU - Perkins, Jeremy
AU - Sieunarine, Kishore
AU - Attia, Doaa
AU - Atef, Mahmoud
AU - Eftychios, Lostoridis
AU - Weaver, Fred
AU - Ren, Leong Chuo
AU - Alomari, Mohannad
AU - Jamjoom, Reda
AU - Aljarrah, Qusai
AU - Abbas, Ayman
AU - Alomran, Faris
AU - Kumar, Ambrish
AU - Altoijri, Abdulmajeed
AU - ElSanhoury, Kareem T.
AU - Alhumaid, Ahmed
AU - Fekry, Tamer
AU - Sekhar, Raghuram
AU - Theodoridis, Panagiotis
AU - Panagiotis, Theodoridis
AU - Roditis, Konstantinos
AU - Tsiantoula, Paraskevi
AU - Antoniou, Afroditi
AU - Soler, Raphael
AU - Hasemaki, Natasha
AU - Baili, Efstratia
AU - Mpaili, Eustratia
AU - Huasen, Bella
AU - Wallace, Tom
AU - Duncan, Andrew
AU - Metcalfe, Matthew
AU - Mannoia, Kristyn
AU - Bechara, Carlos F.
AU - Tsilimparis, Nikolaos
AU - Aranson, Nathan
AU - Riding, David
AU - Palena, Mariano
AU - McDonnell, Ciarán
AU - Mouawad, Nicolas J.
AU - Banegas, Shonda
AU - Rossi, Peter
AU - Oshodi, Taohid
AU - Diaz, Rodney
AU - Afifi, Rana
AU - Dindyal, Shiva
AU - Thapar, Ankur
AU - Kordzadeh, Ali
AU - Pullas, Gonzalo
AU - Lin, Stephanie
AU - Davies, Chris
AU - Darvall, Katy
AU - Kodama, Akio
AU - Gooneratne, Thushan
AU - Gunawansa, Nalaka
N1 - Funding Information:
The study has received financial grant support from the Circulation Foundation (Vascular charity, no grant reference). The National Institute for Health Research (NIHR) has provided salary support for the co-chief investigators (reference: NIHR000359) and co-study leads (reference: NIHR202011). The funders have not played any role in study design, analysis, or writing of the report.
Funding Information:
The VERN executive committee would like to formally acknowledge the support and collaboration with the following international groups and networks: Vascular Society of Great Britain and Ireland (VSGBI); Rouleaux Club (RC); GLOBALSurg; British Society of Endovascular Therapy (BSET); Singapore Vascular Surgical Collaborative (SingVasc); Vascupedia (European vascular education platform); VASCUNET (global collaboration of International Vascular Registries); Australian and New Zealand Vascular Trials Network (ANZVTN); Audible Bleeding (evidence based podcast, USA); British Society of Interventional Radiology (BSIR); BSIR Trainees (BSIRT); International Working Group in the Diabetic Foot (IWGDF); the European Society of Vascular Surgery (ESVS); European Vascular Surgeons in Training (EVST); and STARSurg (UK based student surgical research network). We would also like to thank Sonia Kandola and the Department of Research and Development at the University Hospitals Coventry and Warwickshire NHS Trust, Coventry, UK (study sponsor site), and Irene Cruikshanks and Thomas Koller for Spanish and German translations. These partner groups and colleagues have enabled dissemination of the study and participation from multiple nations worldwide, which has been invaluable in the success of the COVER study to date.
Publisher Copyright:
© 2022 The Author(s)
PY - 2022/1
Y1 - 2022/1
N2 - Objective: To document the recovery of vascular services in Europe following the first COVID-19 pandemic peak. Methods: An online structured vascular service survey with repeated data entry between 23 March and 9 August 2020 was carried out. Unit level data were collected using repeated questionnaires addressing modifications to vascular services during the first peak (March – May 2020, “period 1”), and then again between May and June (“period 2”) and June and July 2020 (“period 3”). The duration of each period was similar. From 2 June, as reductions in cases began to be reported, centres were first asked if they were in a region still affected by rising cases, or if they had passed the peak of the first wave. These centres were asked additional questions about adaptations made to their standard pathways to permit elective surgery to resume. Results: The impact of the pandemic continued to be felt well after countries’ first peak was thought to have passed in 2020. Aneurysm screening had not returned to normal in 21.7% of centres. Carotid surgery was still offered on a case by case basis in 33.8% of centres, and only 52.9% of centres had returned to their normal aneurysm threshold for surgery. Half of centres (49.4%) believed their management of lower limb ischaemia continued to be negatively affected by the pandemic. Reduced operating theatre capacity continued in 45.5% of centres. Twenty per cent of responding centres documented a backlog of at least 20 aortic repairs. At least one negative swab and 14 days of isolation were the most common strategies used for permitting safe elective surgery to recommence. Conclusion: Centres reported a broad return of services approaching pre-pandemic “normal” by July 2020. Many introduced protocols to manage peri-operative COVID-19 risk. Backlogs in cases were reported for all major vascular surgeries.
AB - Objective: To document the recovery of vascular services in Europe following the first COVID-19 pandemic peak. Methods: An online structured vascular service survey with repeated data entry between 23 March and 9 August 2020 was carried out. Unit level data were collected using repeated questionnaires addressing modifications to vascular services during the first peak (March – May 2020, “period 1”), and then again between May and June (“period 2”) and June and July 2020 (“period 3”). The duration of each period was similar. From 2 June, as reductions in cases began to be reported, centres were first asked if they were in a region still affected by rising cases, or if they had passed the peak of the first wave. These centres were asked additional questions about adaptations made to their standard pathways to permit elective surgery to resume. Results: The impact of the pandemic continued to be felt well after countries’ first peak was thought to have passed in 2020. Aneurysm screening had not returned to normal in 21.7% of centres. Carotid surgery was still offered on a case by case basis in 33.8% of centres, and only 52.9% of centres had returned to their normal aneurysm threshold for surgery. Half of centres (49.4%) believed their management of lower limb ischaemia continued to be negatively affected by the pandemic. Reduced operating theatre capacity continued in 45.5% of centres. Twenty per cent of responding centres documented a backlog of at least 20 aortic repairs. At least one negative swab and 14 days of isolation were the most common strategies used for permitting safe elective surgery to recommence. Conclusion: Centres reported a broad return of services approaching pre-pandemic “normal” by July 2020. Many introduced protocols to manage peri-operative COVID-19 risk. Backlogs in cases were reported for all major vascular surgeries.
KW - AAA
KW - COVID-19
KW - PAD
KW - Survey
KW - Vascular surgery
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85143657533&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.1016/j.ejvsvf.2022.10.002
DO - 10.1016/j.ejvsvf.2022.10.002
M3 - Article
C2 - 36281225
AN - SCOPUS:85143657533
SN - 2666-688X
VL - 57
SP - 28
EP - 34
JO - EJVES Vascular Forum
JF - EJVES Vascular Forum
ER -